Archive for October 2007

East Area Committee meeting on 1st November

The East Area Committee meets on 1st November at 7.30, Cherry Trees Day Centre, St Matthews St.

The Tesco planning applications will not be on the agenda; however, it is an opportunity for the public to ask questions of the East Area councillors. We will be present, and all are welcome to come.

The agenda [PDF file] has now been published.

There has not yet been an announcement regarding when the planning applications will be considered.

Map to Cherry Trees Day Centre, St Matthew’s Street:

View Larger Map

Man in the Moon pub on Norfolk Street – open mic night

Tonight, Tuesday 30th October 2007, the Man in the Moon pub on Norfolk Street is hosting an open mic night which will discuss the No Mill Road Tesco campaign.

If you’re in the area, please go along!

Local Secrets – ‘Tesco on Mill Road: readers speak out’

Stay away from Mill Road! said Local Secrets readers who responded to our call for comments on the proposed Tesco on Mill Road. Most praised the diversity of Mill Road, noted the high number of Tesco branches already in Cambridge and warned of damage to such a well-loved place. “It will be completely out of keeping with the present atmosphere of lovely small local shops”, said respondent. “When I was a lad Mill Road was Diagon Alley to my dad”, said another. Just like the hidden street for wizards in the Harry Potter books, Mill Road was talked of as magical, worth preserving and something firmly better off without one more chain store.

But not everyone had scorn to pour on chains. “I would love to see Woolworths opening… I have to keep travelling to Newmarket to shop in their branch”.

When word got out recently that Tesco were applying for planning permission to support the opening of a new express store on the former Wilco site on Mill Road, a grass roots campaign was launched in opposition. ‘Say No to Mill Road Tesco Campaign’ spokesman Richard Rippon said the action awakened “the sense of community… Tesco showed us what is here”.

The campaign has focused on concerns about anti-competitive practices, the increased volume of traffic another store would bring and the threat a chain store brings to Cambridge’s most diverse shopping thoroughfare. “Mill Road is something worth preserving for the whole of Cambridge” added Rippon. Campaigners have spearheaded a petition to the City Council with over 4,000 names along with 800 objections by email and more by post.

An extraordinary meeting by the planning department scheduled to for the end of November will deal with the large number of objections. Local politicians across the parties have also shown keenness to be have a say, including Cambridge MP David Howarth, and leader of the council Ian Nimmo-Smith who has just referred Tesco to the Office of Fair Trading.

Retail giant Tesco already has three regular supermarkets in the city and four smaller express-style stores. As Tesco Corporate Affairs manager Michael Kissman told Local Secrets, over 90% of the urban UK has a choice of three supermarkets within a 15 minute drive, “Why would one more be a problem?” The proposed Mill Road Tesco is in the final stage of planning, with current applications pending for minor alterations to existing pre-approval. Kissman said the store would bring 20 full and part time jobs to the area and most customers would visit on foot. A meeting is currently being scheduled between the campaigners and Tesco representatives.

CEN article: Tesco extends olive branch to Mill Road

SUPERMARKET giant Tesco has said it wants to hear from people living in Cambridge’s Mill Road area about what they think of the company’s plans to open up there.Tesco is planning to meet residents, councillors and David Howarth, MP for Cambridge, right, to talk about its plans and said it wants to hear feedback directly from local people.

A spokesman said the company felt some people had “misunderstood the scale of our plans”.

More than 4,000 people have now signed a petition against plans to open a Tesco Express store in Mill Road.

Coun Ian Nimmo-Smith, leader of Cambridge City Council, has even written to the Office of Fair Trading asking for the competition commission to investigate the supermarket’s operations in the city.

Tesco has submitted a planning application for new signage, a cash machine and an extension at the back of the former Wilco premises.

Representatives of the company have met with planning officers to discuss the application.

A company spokesman said: “It was useful for us to hear the feedback of local people. Some groups appear to have misunderstood the scale of our plans. We are proposing a small convenience store that will actually be smaller than the Co-op currently on Mill Road.

“We were able to explain that most customers will come to the store on foot or bike and not by car. We also explained that the deliveries would be handled by small vehicles appropriate to the streets of Cambridge. Anyone expecting 40ft articulated trucks need not worry.

“I am delighted that we have been able to arrange a time to meet some local residents because we want to be a part of the community.”

Mr Howarth said there were still concerns about Tesco’s delivery policy and confirmed he would be meeting the company.

Sonia Cooter, co-ordinator of the No Mill Road Tesco Campaign, said: “It is clear that Tesco has underestimated the strength of public feeling against their plan to open a store on Mill Road.

“Any attempt to consult with the community at this late stage in the planning process seems rather patronising. We think the opinions of the people who live, work and shop on Mill Road are more important than that.

“We are certainly willing to listen to whatever Tesco representatives have to say to us, but at this stage in the planning process any meeting with Tesco can’t really involve any more than that.”

Cambridge Evening News, 29 October 2007

Mail on Sunday article: ‘Residents fight plans for eighth Tesco in their city’

Neil Craven, Mail on Sunday

Tesco is facing its fiercest campaign yet from locals who are opposed to its store opening plans.

Councillors in Cambridge have complained to the Office of Fair Trading over plans for a new store when Tesco already has seven shops in the area.The campaign, which has secured 4,000 signatures on a petition, comes at an embarrassing moment for the supermarket giant, which is awaiting the results of a competition-inquiry. The Competition-Commission’s probe, an update on which could be released as early as this week, has examined all the big supermarket groups.

A central feature of its investigation is likely to be Tesco’s land bank and its allegedly aggressive techniques used to win planning applications.

In a letter sent to the Office of Fair Trading and seen by Financial Mail, Cambridge’s Liberal Democrat council leader Ian Nimmo-Smith complains that Tesco already has three Express stores, three supermarkets and an Extra superstore in the area. The group hopes to open a fourth Express store.

That compares with four stores shared among Asda, Sainsbury’s and Waitrose and a range of smaller discount and convenience stores.

Nimmo-Smith said Tesco’s planned store was ‘unacceptable’.

The Mail on Sunday, 28 October 2007

Suspicious survey

We have had a few reports of local people receiving a survey about ‘supermarkets’ from ABA Market Research. (This may or may not be connected to the current Mill Road proposals.)

The survey is at .

It deals with specific postcode areas (Cambridge, Watford and Wigan).

We have received reports that, at various points, the message ‘sorry you do not fall within our category’ is received if responses like ‘I made very few visits to Tesco’ are received. Another part of the survey, it has been reported to us, asks you to tell them why you are shopping at Tesco more than any other supermarket.

Please let us know if you receive a request to fill in a survey of this nature.

Facts and figures – Tesco/supermarkets

We have researched some facts and figures about Tesco which may make interesting reading…

Supporting groups growing

A large number of groups have confirmed their support for our Campaign to stop Tesco coming to Mill Road. These including local community groups, the majority of political parties active in the area, and Cambridge’s MP.

Please contact us if your group wishes to be added to the list.

Photos from first public meeting

Here are some photos from the meeting. Thanks to Jemima Willcox for these.

Please contact us if you need a larger version.

CEN article: Leader steps up Tesco shop war

Tesco has been reported to the Office of Fair Trading.

Coun Ian Nimmo-Smith, leader of Cambridge City Council, has written to the watchdog asking for an investigation into Tesco’s bid to open an Express store in Mill Road, Cambridge.

He has asked for the plans to be scrutinised by the Competition Commission due to the “current dominance of Tesco within the local retail area and the likely adverse affect on a diverse but fragile range of local independent shops and services”.

He has urged the OFT to act before the planning application is decided next month.

Continue reading ‘CEN article: Leader steps up Tesco shop war’ »